【loans for workers compensation claims】Pressure on small brokers grows a year after new EU rules
By Helen Reid,loans for workers compensation claims Simon Jessop and Josephine Mason
LONDON (Reuters) - A year after new EU rules forced banks and brokers to charge investors for equity research, the pressure on small brokerages to make ends meet is becoming intense and more look set to merge or even shut up shop in 2019.
According to dozens of executives at major hedge funds, asset managers, banks and brokerages, the picture looks bleak for smaller brokers who are being undercut by large banks and face increasingly cost-conscious asset managers.
Smaller brokerages have far less clout in negotiating contracts with investors, forcing some to cut prices or research, carve out a niche with bespoke research or, in more drastic cases, team up with a rival or close.
The aim of the EU's Markets in Financial Instruments Directive II (MiFID II) was to increase transparency and ensure investors got a fairer deal, but the dominance of the big banks is also pushing some regulators to have a rethink.
"MiFID is going to have continued significant ramifications. I always felt the fourth quarter (2018) or first quarter (2019) would be when the change starts to bite," said Steven Fine, chief executive at mid- and small-cap broker Peel Hunt.
Before MiFID II came into force in January 2018, banks and brokerages bundled the cost of research into their overall charges for executing customer trades, or gave it away free.
Under the new EU rules, they must bill institutional investors for everything from research to meetings to conference calls, and separate research from execution fees.
Itemising the services has caused havoc.
U.S. bank JPMorgan Chase (JPM.N) led the charge in 2017 before the rules came in by offering research subscriptions to investors for as little as $10,000 (7,837 pounds) a year, a fraction of the six or seven figure sums some smaller boutique firms had hoped for.
'MORE RADICAL'
The move roiled Europe's fragmented stockbroking sector and put pressure on rivals to follow suit or risk losing business.
One year into Europe's big experiment, data from Greenwich Associates shows 60 percent of research services are still handled by the global investment banks, suggesting they have not loosened their grip on the market since the new rules came in.
While large investment banks are more willing to fund their research teams to maintain their edge in equity capital markets, the pressure is only set to get worse for smaller rivals and the small companies they cover, executives said.
Recent merger talks between Australian investment bank Macquarie and UK broker Liberum were a sign of things to come in 2019, said Nigel Bolton, co-head of fundamental equities at BlackRock, the world's biggest asset manager.
"That's the sign that brokerages and banks are saying 'now we've been trying this for a year, it's not improving, we're going to have to do something more radical'. And I think you will see that happening in 2019."
Market regulators in the UK and France have raised concerns about the impact of a subsequent decline in research coverage and trading liquidity for smaller firms - and may yet take action.
In an interview with the Financial Times in November, the head of the French markets watchdog, Robert Ophele, said MiFID had had "very detrimental" effects on research, particularly of midcap companies, and called for a review of the legislation.
The fragmented nature of the UK market means brokerages there are undergoing the biggest change, but firms in the euro zone are also under pressure.
In November, AllianceBernstein (AB.N) announced plans to buy Autonomous Research, an independent firm with offices in London, New York and Hong Kong and more than 35 analysts.
German private bank Berenberg has laid off staff in its equities business amid pressure from MiFID II, the Financial Times reported last year.
Others, including London's Numis Corp (NUM.L) and Peel Hunt, say they are expanding research teams to fill a gap left from cutbacks by rivals.
Peel Hunt's Fine says he won't budge on the prices his company charges, and expects the impact of the loss of some research clients to be cushioned by revenues elsewhere in the business, including corporate finance.
Still, pressure on research prices may be here to stay, with asset managers in a strong bargaining position.
Finding it hard to charge the bill to investors, most asset managers are paying for it themselves and using less, leading to a slide in total industry spend of about 30 percent.
NOT PAYING
Penny pinching led to an average budget cut by asset managers of about 20 percent in 2018, with a reduction of another 5 percent to 6 percent expected in 2019, according to Greenwich Associates research.
Asset managers are also expected to reduce the number of research and advisory firms they use to 15.3 in 2019, from 15.7 last year and 20 in 2015, it said.
Richard Buxton, chief executive of Merian Global Investors, said his firm began pricing research separately before the new rules kicked in, with year-on-year budget reductions of 10 percent that should continue in 2019.
"We don't want waterfront coverage from a whole raft of big firms. It's 'we like your analysts in these three sectors and everything else, frankly, we're not prepared to pay for'."
Matthias Desmarais, head of research at broker Oddo BHF in Paris, said he expected more cuts in research budgets when talks with providers kick off in 2019 - before brokers recover some pricing power from 2020.
BlackRock's Bolton was not so sure.
He said his team's research spending would stay lower as managers think twice about paying for a broker's research or access to their analysts - with quarterly reviews and a massive monitoring and reporting exercise to check usage and spending.
One hour with an analyst can cost as much as 1,000 pounds.
Stiffer competition has also forced brokerages to look at selling their wares in new ways.
RSRCHXchange, an online marketplace for research, said the number of firms selling research on its site has doubled to 400 since January 2017. "People want to monetise their research more than ever before," co-founder Jeremy Davies said.
(Reporting by Helen Reid, Simon Jessop and Jospehine Mason in London, Inti Landauro and Blandine Henault in Paris; editing by David Clarke)
View comments
-
The Wizz Air Holdings (LON:WIZZ) Share Price Has Gained 160%, So Why Not Pay It Some Attention?At S$0.22, Is Indofood Agri Resources Ltd. (SGX:5JS) Worth Looking At Closely?Report says Trump demanded top-secret clearance for KushnerAnother Look at ‘Super Options’SHAREHOLDER ACTION NOTICE: The Schall Law Firm Announces the Filing of a Class Action Lawsuit Against Align Technology, Inc. and Encourages Investors with Losses in Excess of $100,000 to Contact the FirmServices sector activity growth slows in June: MarkitFOCUS-Budweiser spends big on Super Bowl, targets small marketsIs Franklin Natural Resources A (FRNRX) a Strong Mutual Fund Pick Right Now?US warns 7 companies over fraudulent coronavirus claimsCould The HKBN Ltd. (HKG:1310) Ownership Structure Tell Us Something Useful?
下一篇:Rand Capital Corp. to Host Earnings Call
- ·JPMorgan Chase approved to process $15 billion in new PPP loans
- ·US STOCKS SNAPSHOT-Wall Street edges up; economic concerns cap gains
- ·Investors Are Undervaluing Fellow Finance Oyj (HEL:FELLOW) By 46.67%
- ·Amazon's Earnings Were Strong, but Its Outlook Disappointed: 5 Metrics You Should See
- ·Vineyard Wind picks GE turbines for Massachusetts offshore wind farm
- ·Is It Smart To Buy Shoe Carnival, Inc. (NASDAQ:SCVL) Before It Goes Ex-Dividend?
- ·BRIEF-Bumi Armada Posts Q4 Net Loss 1.26 Bln RGT
- ·How Much Did CSE Global Limited's (SGX:544) CEO Pocket Last Year?
- ·Sherwin-Williams (SHW): Strong Growth And Abundant Potential
- ·CymaBay Therapeutics (NASDAQ:CBAY) Is In A Good Position To Deliver On Growth Plans
- ·Robuxgenerator Inc Launches Free Robux Generator to Get Free Robux in 2022 without Verification
- ·First Circuit Declares Appointment of FOMB Members Violates Appointments Clause
- ·Rohingya must have choice on going to Bangladesh island - UN refugee agency
- ·Apple's iPhone sales leave investors feeling sour as they wait to hear from the Fed
- ·Wesco International (WCC) Q4 2018 Earnings Conference Call Transcript
- ·FOREX-Dollar scales 10-week high vs yen on upbeat U.S. GDP
- ·Global Compression Garments Market – Analysis By Product Type, By End User, By Region, By Country (2020 Edition): Market Insights, COVID-19 Impact, Competition and Forecast (2020-2025)
- ·Roku to launch subscription video channels business
- ·Is B2Gold (TSE:BTO) A Risky Investment?
- ·Hawaii avocado industry expects growth as exports begin
- ·CEO Talks: Boucheron’s Hélène Poulit-Duquesne Takes the Positive View
- ·Backstop is only solution to Irish border issue - German justice minister
- ·Are You the Right Investor for U.S. Oil and Gas Royalty Trusts? In Depth Analysis of Expectations for Future Cash Flows Before an Investment Decision Is Required
- ·The Latest: Apple axes Google access to key developer tool
- ·AT&T Stock Falls 4%
- ·Was the 9 Percent Drop in the S&P 500 Really Just a 'Glitch' Like President Trump Says?
- ·Visa's (V) Program to Aid Asia Pacific Startups Thrive Globally
- ·These are the 6 hottest crypto tokens you can use to buy real estate in the metaverse
- ·Who Has Been Buying Pulmonx Corporation (NASDAQ:LUNG) Shares?
- ·BDs 'Gearing Up, Committing Dollars and Hiring Staff' in 2019
- ·StockBeat: No Hiding Place (Except Tesco)
- ·Shop Samsung deals on smartphones, TVs, accessories and more for the new year
- ·Should You Be Impressed By Class Limited's (ASX:CL1) ROE?
- ·A Focus on Out-of-Favor, Overlooked and Misunderstood Securities with Strong Balance Sheets Key to This Manager's Portfolio Construction Strategy
- ·The Global Cloud Encryption Software Market is expected to grow by $ 2.82 bn during 2020-2024 progressing at a CAGR of 38% during the forecast period
- ·Toronto Blue Jays Announcer Fired For “Inappropriate Behavior” With Women